Required rant of: I haven’t blogged in a year, I’m worst. Yadda yadda yadda
This blog post is going to be a response to the New York Times article “Where Have All the Tomboys Gone?” and all the stupid comments made on it, because screw you, I need to vent.
I will say I was a tomboy. I still am, if adult women can be considered tomboys. I find tomboy fairly easy to define, and since people seem not to have the same definition, here’s mine: A tomboy is a girl who prefers “rough and tumble” play. She is not afraid to get dirty, and tends to be very comfortable with boys and “boy” activities. Often, she is more comfortable in pants than skirts but she still considers herself a girl.
The quote of Liz Prince in the article could very well have been said by me:
“If you’re in high school and still dressing like that, people think you’re definitely a lesbian,” Ms. Prince said. “But I wanted to wear boys’ clothes and make out with them, too.”
That’s about it, to me. A tomboy is a girl that prefers the aesthetics of “boys” and doesn’t really have much to do beyond that.
The article itself is pretty good, I feel. The only thing that gave me pause was that the term “tomboy” is out-of-date and that the phrase “gender non-conforming” would be more accurate. I don’t disagree with this statement, but I feel like the phrase could be misleading. I feel like some people may think that someone is transgender, which I am not. I was born female, and feel female, I just don’t feel “girly.” That’s my only real problem with the article itself.
But the comments. Oh god, the comments.
I’m going to take a few of the comments and yell at them like an old man yells at a cloud.
- Mary says: “If only equality didn’t mean that everyone has to be male-like to succeed. Just because men rule basically everything doesn’t mean that we should dress like them or act like them. We should be permitted to be the lawyer, the boss, the whatever without adopting male clothes and testosterone-fueled aggression. It’s not the dress code that is the problem, it’s unequal pay, violence against women, and invidious discrimination in all aspects of life. I’m in favor of gender identity; I just don’t think it has to be male to be good.”
Mary, Mary, Mary. No. That is not the point. I don’t feel like I need to adopt male clothes and “testosterone-fueled aggression” to be successful. I am, and was, simply being who I am comfortable being. Someone decided to give it a name and we ran with it.
2. Pooteeweet says: “Well, these days there’s a concerted effort to convince girls who would’ve been tomboys in the past, that they’re transgender.”
Pooteeweet, you ignorant slut. Transgender and tomboy is not the same. I have never felt that I was in the wrong body as transgender people do. I feel out of place in a dress, not my body.
3. RefLib says: “When I was growing up, I thought being called a tomboy was a badge of honor. It meant that I was welcome to play with the boys and I could keep up. We lived on the edge of a town by wilderness and I loved to play in creeks, ride horses, play army, or build forts with anyone who would, boy or girl. It didn’t matter to me. I didn’t want to be a boy. I also liked dressing up, reading books, playing with dolls. I had it all! I want that for everyone.”
See, RefLib (obviously a smarty being a reference librarian) gets it and me. Hell, I could have written this comment. After the age of 5 there were no girls my age in my neighborhood. While I did have a male friend who was into “girly” stuff with me, most of the time I was tailing along with my brother and his friends, weaseling my way into street hockey games. The “girly” stuff I liked had to wait until I was with my cousin, so I embraced the “boy” stuff.
4. avery_t says: Katniss.
Alos, Beyonce’s dancing is more athletic than most traditional tomboy activities.
Tomboys were girls unafraid of physical activities. Now, in the media, there’s Katniss, Ronda Rousey, and twerking. Hip hop lent an athleticism to femininity that didn’t exist in the disco era.
I don’t really have anything to add to this comment. I like it a lot. 4 for you avery_t, you go avery_t.
There are more comments, many of them supporting the term and activities of “tomboy” many of them just being pedantic and annoying.
Is tomboy kind of an outdated term? In my opinion, yes and no. If someone were to be describing someone to me, they could expedite things by describing a girl as a tomboy. But I do feel that the differences between “boy stuff” and “girl stuff” is being blurred, as it should be.
Tomboy is getting harder to define, as girls are not being held to the same standards that they once were. Womens’ sports are more prevalent (Btw, check out the new National Women’s Hockey League, I’m trying to decide which team I’m going to root for) and “boyfriend” fashions are in (again).
But if you ask me if I’m a tomboy, the answer is still “yes.”